Where did all the Shops go?
Jan 15
According to a Wall Street Journal article ("Shoppers Are Fleeing Physical Stores"), U.S. retailers are facing a steep and persistent drop in store traffic. Shopper visits have fallen by 5% or more from a year earlier in every month for the past two years, according to ShopperTrak, a Chicago-based data firm that records store visits for retailers using tracking devices installed at 40,000 U.S. outlets. Another article ("Where Have all the Shoppers Gone?", FORTUNE, September, 2014), suggests that retailers continue to face a "Darwinian struggle for survival", which will ultimately take down some of the best-known brands. This year's "Black Friday" results confirm the troubling downward path for brick–and--mortar stores, showing a 10.3 percent drop in sales, down from $11.6 billion in 2014 to $10.4 billion this year. Online sales on the same day grew 14 percent from last year, bringing in a total of $2.72 billion.
The number of buying options available to consumer will continues to grow. As a recent Cisco survey of retail trends discovered, e-commerce has added about 40 possible shopping options for a typical shopper. With the rise of the Internet of Everything (IoE) -- the explosion in networked connections of people process, data, and things -- potential shopping journeys will expand to 800 and beyond. Some of the new options coming into play could include mobile devices equipped for live Web engagements, checkout optimization, mobile payments, wearables, augmented reality, ride-sharing (e.g., Uber same- day delivery launched just over a year ago) and drone delivery.
Finally, consumer discovery is upending the traditional hierarchy of effects model (i.e. awareness---knowledge---liking----preference----conviction----purchase) that has guided marketers for decades and been instrumental in establishing retail brands. For example, unlike traditional advertising, individuals in the social media era have access to content that is not necessarily associated with commercial intent (e.g., to make a purchase); consequently, if a person likes the content, he/she is likely to pass it on to their peers, families, and so on via social sites, then the content will be quickly diffused without the help of traditional marketing.
So, how do you view the prospects of traditional retailers and what do they need to do to survive in the digital age?
William (Bill) Johnson, Ph.D., is a Part-time Participating Faculty in Marketing in the Huizenga College of Business and Entrepreneurship, Nova Southeastern University. He can be reached at billyboy@nova.edu
#1 by JONATHAN PADJEN on 1/15/16 - 2:12 PM
#2 by Rosana on 1/22/16 - 10:13 PM
#3 by Christine Panesso on 3/7/16 - 1:53 PM
#4 by Sisleidy Reyes on 3/7/16 - 7:57 PM
#5 by Eva Goldstein on 3/7/16 - 9:30 PM
#6 by Karen A Pinnock on 3/8/16 - 10:24 AM
#7 by Aaliyah Jenkins on 3/8/16 - 8:35 PM
#8 by Fabian Montero on 3/8/16 - 11:08 PM
#9 by Dana Anderson on 3/9/16 - 9:08 AM
#10 by Marilyn Despagne on 3/9/16 - 2:25 PM
#11 by Merlin Forero on 3/9/16 - 11:57 PM
#12 by Hayley Miller on 3/10/16 - 7:34 AM
#13 by Erika Leogue on 3/10/16 - 1:26 PM
Although rare, I sometimes venture to the mall. It always seems empty, much like a ghost town void of the vibrant commotion of excited shoppers pushing their way through every department store or boutique they could walk through. It may be that forecasters have validity in their predictions.
I have become an online shopper. I prefer the convenience of shopping for everything I need and having it delivered to my door without ever having to pack up and load my bags in the car and drag my kid to the store just to buy a blouse. However, I do not believe the brick-and-mortar shops are all out of luck.
There is something to the touch and feel of a product versus a picture online, instant delivery and having a face-to-face exchange while purchasing. Another student commented that having a professional staff is essential to the shopping experience. I absolutely agree. This is true of an online experience or a face-to-face exchange; but brick stores run a greater risk of losing a sale if a shopper asks for help and the staff cannot assist satisfactorily. I personally can attest to that!
Another option for brick-and-mortar shops may be to offer something the online experience can't. I may very well get up and pack up the kids if the store I intend to visit offers me some greater incentive, for example, 1/2 off lunch, a free Starbucks coffee and a discount for walking in to their store, not to mention a safe place for my daughter to play while I shop, that is, a place that I can visually monitor from my phone with a professional staff to supervise the kids. Yes, that would certainly make a pleasurable outing for me and my kid; that is something that the IoE cannot offer. Perhaps, some brick stores may have attempted such incentives, but they may need to review or upgrade their offers. If moms are the target market, then making their lives easier, with a little indulgence/pampering and savings goes a long, long way to increasing customer experience/satisfaction and, ultimately, a store's bottom line!
#14 by Antonio Diaz on 3/10/16 - 2:50 PM
My opinion to this article is that there is a decrease in consumer traffic ant brick and mortar store locations and this traffic is going to the online store for shopping. I think that there will never be an end to the brick and mortar store locations and its foot traffic but it will be substantially less than it was a few years ago. I believe that there will never be a substitute to the physical, brick and mortar, store front shopping experience. It will struggle but not be completely phased out, I believe.
#15 by Christine Panesso on 3/10/16 - 11:12 PM
#16 by Ann-Marie Fraser on 3/11/16 - 10:22 AM
#17 by Andrea Mitchell on 3/11/16 - 9:08 PM
For example, the article cited store closings for Sears and RadioShack. These two stores cannot compete with the Best Buy’s, HH Gregg, Home Depot’s, etc. Both of these stores should have improved their branding and brand equity images. For years, Sears has relied on their appliance sales to sustain them and RadioShack has relied on its electronics. However, both of these chains retail stores have a “feel” of where your grandparents would shop.
Finally, in regards to the increase in Black Friday online sales, I think that is because retailers like, Walmart and BestBuy, offer free shipping to the store. Coincidentally, this option helps to decrease the number of consumers in the stores on Black Friday, reducing stampedes and flared tempers and reduces the liability for the retailer. Consumers no longer feel the pressure of having to be first in line or that the item will sell out before they can get to the store to make their purchase. It’s a win-win for everyone: Retailer makes a sale and consumer have their item.
References
Khan, I. (2015, December 10). What is IoT? Why it Matters and What You Should Do! Retrieved from Huffington Post: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ian-khan/what-is-iot...
#18 by Angie Joselin on 3/12/16 - 12:52 PM
#19 by Jordan Ufer on 3/12/16 - 2:21 PM
#20 by Watson Florvilus on 3/12/16 - 2:52 PM
#21 by Clara Cortez on 3/13/16 - 12:39 AM
#22 by Dave Davis on 3/13/16 - 11:20 AM
#23 by Shiralee Chokshi on 3/13/16 - 9:09 PM
#24 by Kelly Ferreira de Souza on 3/13/16 - 9:18 PM
Embracing the digital age can create value and satisfaction at a new level. The company will not only market its products but it will market itself. Creating a loyal customer, because of their experience shopping. In times of changes, being the leader and having loyal customers can secure a company's survival.
#25 by Alanna Butterfield on 3/13/16 - 10:05 PM
#26 by Dr. Johnson on 3/14/16 - 8:23 AM
http://www.forbes.com/sites#/sites/danielkleinman/...
#27 by Diego Soto Gonzalez on 3/14/16 - 2:00 PM
If we investigate more about shopping online we can see also some important disadvantages, as it was researched the main difficulties and concerns of the people are that “Government and industry organizations have declared information privacy and security to be major obstacles in the development of consumer-related e-commerce”. (Miyazaki & Fernandez, 2001). Obviously, this is a significant problem, if there are some threads of hackers taking private information or credit card information, most of the people are not going to feel safe and they will prefer to go to the malls and swipe their cards or pay cash.
In my opinion, traditional retailers will survive digital age. As we see in my post there are a lot of advantages on buying online, however there are some important disadvantages too. Traditional retailers will keep being better in terms of privacy and security. Also, old people might not be that Internet savvy and they will keep buying everything in traditional retailers. But I also think that traditional retailers should keep developing and making things easier for the consumers. Personally, I do most of my shopping in traditional retailers and I only use online shopping for cheap and meaningless things.
References:
Wolfinbarger, M., & Gilly, M. C. (2001). Shopping online for freedom, control, and fun. California Management Review, 43(2), 34-55.
Miyazaki, A. D., & Fernandez, A. (2001). Consumer perceptions of privacy and security risks for online shopping. Journal of Consumer affairs, 35(1), 27-44.
#28 by Brittany Wilson on 3/16/16 - 4:22 PM
#29 by Carolina Belmonte on 3/16/16 - 9:59 PM
In a society that has always craved instant gratification, online shipping is the pinnacle of such. You hear about this awesome product on Facebook, you follow the company's Instagram or check out their Pinterest, then you end up on their e-commerce sight and BOOM...in less than an hour you've caught to the latest trend without leaving the comfort of your couch.
To those that argue that traditional retailers can fight this trend offering unbeatable face-to-face customer service, I say nay. This may work for some time, but have you considered the value of a good call center combined with low-hassle policies?
To those that argue that there will always be a specialized niche of shoppers for traditional retailers, I somewhat agree. However, niches are complicated and not the place to look for big profits (and ultimately, isn't this a company's end game?). There are some exceptions that come to mind, like grocery stores the likes of Publix. There's just something that feels off about buying my produce and such online, but in the I believe that even these basic needs will one day be met primarily through online shopping.
Most Americans, myself included, are technophiles. Let's embrace this migration of shopping preferences and let's learn more about our online habits. I am fascinated by how our marketing efforts are adapting to this era and look forward to what the future has in store.
#30 by Khalil Sutton on 3/17/16 - 8:57 AM
I agree with Fabian Moore, customers’ connection to the brick and mortar store lies in the inherent connection between physical interaction and positive consumer feelings, something which is harder for online retailers/marketplaces to replicate. But, to mitigate the cost differences brick and mortar stores have to create a hybrid, efficient storefront, eliminate huge storefronts, create more warehouses, and a more linear approach to creating a pipeline from online marketplace (where millions of products are listed ) directly to the consumers hand.
#31 by Kelly Hunter on 3/17/16 - 9:24 AM
#32 by Karen A Pinnock on 3/17/16 - 10:18 AM
#33 by Evan on 3/17/16 - 7:29 PM
I worked for Nike for three years while doing my undergrad in the foot-wear department. Our team of employees were required to understand the different types of shoes and why they would benefit certain types of people. We had a focus to achieve their goals, whether it was to run a 5k or walk more comfortably, we all had the product knowledge that would surprise the typical shopper and would leave the store with a problem solved. If we didn't have that knowledge and service, the consumer might have just looked online, read the reviews and decided to purchase on their own.
#34 by Patricia Newman on 3/17/16 - 8:31 PM
Reference
Deneen, K., Yu, D. (2015). Online shopping is making many customers antagonistic. Retrieved from http://www.gallup.com/businessjournal/182006/onlin...
#35 by Jose Arroliga on 3/19/16 - 3:48 PM
I used to work for Perry Ellis and I was a part of a couple of store openings as a retail allocator. I was responsible for ordering all items inside the two new stores from pants and shirts to neckties or socks. I recently went to one of the stores we opened (Dolphin Mall, Miami, Florida) and discovered they had changed spaces within the mall. They had moved to a smaller location displaying only their signature items I believe this will be the new trend for retail stores. Offering the customers their top 10-15 items and leaving the rest to their online market thus resulting in better customer service and strengthen customer experience.
#36 by Aaliyah Jenkins on 3/19/16 - 6:29 PM
Reference
Hortaçsu, A., & Syverson, C.. (2015). The Ongoing Evolution of US Retail: A Format Tug-of-War. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 29(4), 89–111. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/43611012
#37 by Esmeralda Castellon on 3/19/16 - 6:31 PM
In addition, there was also another interesting point that another blogger commented about physical stores like Publix where there is still a strange feeling about purchasing your produce and food online. Though, many supermarket stores like Publix offer to shop online in my personal opinion I think I like to pick my own tomatoes. However, like it was commented about the blogger this soon may be another new aspect that people might want to explore if it makes their life easier.
#38 by Maisha Mitchell on 3/20/16 - 12:29 AM
However, I do not foresee traditional retailers disappearing completely, due to what my classmate Karen Pinnock mentioned in her comment, that there are times online purchase such as clothing do not always live up to expectations. For instance, there was one time when I order a dress online for my company’s Christmas party and it was a complete let down because it did not fit my shape the way I thought it would and the material looked cheap. In the end, I had to go to the mall and purchase a dress last minute but at least I found something that fit me well. Some individuals rather take the time and go to the mall to try on clothing rather than taking the risk and buying it online. Nevertheless, many retailers have made the decision to take action by becoming hybrid. What I mean by hybrid is that they are engaging in “reintermediation” and becoming brick-and-click retailers, adding online services to their offerings (Kotler & Keller, 2016, p. 9). I am in agreeance with my classmate Eva Goldstein, who stated that the only way that traditional retailers can distinguish themselves is by creating an experience that cannot be done online. According to Kotler and Keller (2016), “…entrepreneurial retailers are building entertainment into their stores with coffee bars, demonstrations, and performance, marketing an “experience” rather than the product” (p. 9). Personally, I would continue to go to the mall for clothing and only participate in online shopping for tech items or other items such as books, watches, shoes etc.
Reference
Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). A framework for marketing management.
#39 by Noelle Mena on 3/20/16 - 3:07 PM
In all actuality I would only see the benefit on shopping online if: (a) you have time and don’t mind waiting for the turnaround times in shipping and handling; (b) you have some time of shopping or social anxiety disorder that prevents you from going to a mall or store. Social anxiety is defined as a “marked and persistent fear of social or performance situations” and includes such symptoms as sweating, palpitations, shaking, and respiratory distress. Social anxiety is fairly common, occurring in as much as 13% of the population, and can be extremely disabling. (Jefferson, 2001, p. 1); or (c) you have a physical handicap that prevents you from moving around.
Therefore, if stores do want to do well, I would suggest incorporating a brick and mortar establishment along with a digital style store, that way it gives clients both options, since limiting options can be cumbersome for retail stores, especial at start up this would give stores competitive advantage over some of the more traditional stores that haven’t implemented digital e-stores.
References
Jefferson, J. W. (2001). Social Anxiety Disorder: More Than Just a Little Shyness. Prim. Care Companion J. Clin. Psychiatry, 03(01), 4-9. doi:10.4088/pcc.v03n0102
Study: 85% of Consumers Prefer to Shop at Physical Stores vs. Online | TimeTrade. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.timetrade.com/news/press-releases/study...
#40 by Jeannine Jordan on 3/20/16 - 6:04 PM
I am a big fan of Victoria’s Secret, for example. When I was going to NSU for my undergraduate degree, taking a full course load while working two jobs, I did not have the time to go shopping. If I did, I was trading that for time to spend with my boyfriend. I still wanted to buy nice things for myself like perfume and bathing suits. When I called the store to make my purchase, I was driving from work to class. I told the woman on the other end of the phone that I did not have the time to even look at their website, and asked her if she could pick something out for me. She described a couple items and I picked one, gave her my credit card number that I knew by heart (still driving), and fully trusted that I would enjoy my purchase when it arrived, never having seen what it looks like. Sure, I have my favorite items within the available options, but there really isn’t anything in their store that I particularly do not like. I am pretty confident to say that the majority of other women would say the same. This trust and comfort that I have developed with this brand can be attributed to their amazing marketing teams. Think back to when this retail store only sold lingerie. They realized that would not be enough, and began to provide additional products such as perfumes, makeup, bathing suits, athletic wear, pajamas, slippers, sheets and bedding, etc. This enabled their current loyal customers, most likely a more mature bracket of women, to bring their daughters and friends the same joy that they experience when shopping at this store. When customers love something so much, they will buy two more just so they can gift these items to their friends or family members.
To survive in the digital age, traditional retailers need to get with the times; the new times. Traditional retailers need to rethink and restructure everything that is not soaring with success. They should take to a new customer driven mindset to create revised products and services that are necessary (meeting human and social needs), add in a little flare (they must be incredibly appealing from a visual perspective), and offer convenience that would surpass anybody’s expectation. The newly revised “Captain America” editions need to be over the top products and services; available online and in a store near you. My solution as to how: take surveys from current customers on topics such as what is most appealing to them, provide no purchase necessary incentives for taking the survey to not only find out how to please them, but to get them back in-store ASAP. This will require upfront cost, but if you have a good marketing team that can work with statistics, the payoff will certainly keep you in business.
In conclusion, re-envisioning an old company in a new age is what it takes to survive change. Reassessing the needs and desires of your current market, recreating products and services to match these needs, repositioning your marketing strategy, and redesigning your brand so that it is still familiar may very well be necessary to providing a new and refreshed customer experience with increased satisfaction and value. The retailer’s revamping should consider topics of cultural diversity and social responsibility when coming up with new globalization efforts. When consumers are shopping at a store that actively gives back, it creates a feeling of positivity and content within the customer; as though they are doing a good deed by making the purchase. I firmly believe the care required to provide a personal touch is lacking severely, and that those who do will be our winners in the digital age.
#41 by Andrew Phillips on 3/20/16 - 7:43 PM
#42 by Luis Vega on 3/20/16 - 8:46 PM
I do not believe retail stores will completely disappear however, they will become smaller. The first example would be Best Buy. When you walk into a Best Buy they feel so open. With the change in technology, there is no need for them to have rows and rows of CDs and DVDs.
Retail locations will become more of a pickup location for online shoppers that do not have their purchases delivered to their homes. An example would be stores like Walmart that have the site to store option when shopping online. Shoppers can go to the store to pick up the items they ordered online and can avoid possible shipping charges. I found this option to be very helpful and convenient. Sometimes I purchase items online while at work and pick them up during my lunch hour.
Retailers have to take advantage of technology to increase sales in their stores. Aps like Retail Me Not provide shoppers information on the available coupons for retailers. While standing in line at a store you can open the ap and see what coupons are available. There are some aps that use your location services to show you deals around you and send you a push notification as you walk in the store.
Eventually the concept of building large shopping malls will give way to smaller retail locations. Retailers will need to enhance the shopping experience if they want to attract shoppers.
Luis Vega
#43 by Kristine Kowalski on 3/20/16 - 9:37 PM
#44 by Alanna Butterfield on 3/20/16 - 10:02 PM
I also agree that we will not see the complete demise of brick and mortar stores in the near future. While revenues for eCommerce sales are expected to grow to approximately $150 billion between 2015 - 2018, brick and mortar stores are expected to bring in about $300 billion during the same time period (Agrawal, A. 2016, January 4). I do believe that this gap between online and physical store sales will continue to close unless brick and mortar stores do indeed come up with creative ways to keep their customers coming.
Reference:
Agrawal, A. (2016, January 4). Does eCommerce Success Mean Physical Stores Will Disappear in the Future? Retrieved March 18, 2016, from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/aj-agrawal/does-ecom...
#45 by Michael Garcia on 3/20/16 - 10:33 PM
Target is a great example of a company adapting to customers needs. Target first introduced their online market place using Amazon's platform, over time they have Made multiple adjustments in order integrate Target Mobile and the in-store shopping experience. Target offers the cartwheel application allowing consumers online or in-store to receive discounts off of select merchandise. This application also introduces newly discounted merchandise weekly. Target has also incorporated a feature allowing a consumer to not only check inventory in store, but to locate in which isle the item will be found. Lastly, in order to make a more seamless experience, they offer something that online-only retailers cannot offer ; in-store pickup. This attracts customers who want instant gratification. This provides the ultimate customer experience, the customer places their order and conveniently picks it up within minutes.
#46 by Jeff Arteaga on 3/20/16 - 11:48 PM
It is well known that Millenials drive current economic markets. Even though most are unemployed or underemployed, they still utilize every dime of disposable income on, well… things. Because money does not grow on trees and society thrives on immediacy, Price and Place become key components in the shopping experience. When your hand-held Smartphone can easily find you the cheapest price within driving distance at the touch of a button, barriers to entry fall.
From a consumer standpoint, this seems great! I can get the best product, for the cheapest price, and I can get it right now. What could possibly be bad about that?
Amazon’s strategy to remove overhead costs by not having a brick and mortar store undercut Borders, B Dalton, Books-A-Million, and so many others. Bezos has nearly created a monopoly on the book selling market. If Amazon succeeds, that cheaper book you celebrated buying today… Amazon can set any price on it. Without competition, consumers have no alternative and the free market ceases.
It’s a little ironic that Sears and Radio Shack are closing doors while Amazon has moved towards opening several new ones. With literature, consumers felt safe knowing that they don’t have to hold the book or see it up close to agree what they bought is what they’ll get. However, other purchases, like electronics, may not be so easily trusted. Before dropping big bucks on single products, consumers want proof their purchase is justified. Having an actual store solves this issue. It also adds to that immediacy society craves; why wait for free shipping when you can pick it up right now?
In the future, we should not be so consumed with where we will get purchases or how we will receive them. We should be concentrating our efforts on the quality of a purchase and the state of the overall market.
#47 by Christopher Jean on 3/21/16 - 10:58 PM
Christopher Jean
#48 by Marisleydis Bruguez on 5/9/16 - 2:50 PM
I think that what store need to do is sell more of the actual experience that shopping is about. From my personal experience shopping is more socializing than anything else. For example, when I go to the mall more than often than not I go with friends and even if am just going to accompany them I always end up buying something. So for us is more of being able to spend time there and talk and yes shop. So they should advertise more the family and socialize aspect of going to the actual stores, motivate people to take the extra time out of their schedules.
#49 by Travoy Forbes on 5/10/16 - 8:24 AM
In my opinion, traditional retailers will need to drastically improve their customer service and experience, find a way to stay competitive with the online retailers’ prices and product availability. There is also a need to accurately value products and get back to being honest and transparent so that customers can again gain faith in the traditional retail stores and start coming back through the doors. Traditional retailers need to market themselves as products on the shelves, consumers are looking for products they can trust and services they are comfortable with. Traditional retailers need to accomplish that.
#50 by Hugh Cunningham on 5/16/16 - 11:26 PM
#51 by Willy Vargas on 5/17/16 - 11:23 PM
#52 by Andres Vargas on 5/18/16 - 12:27 AM
The marketing plan should unfold the new challenges and the executives must come with innovative ways to retain aging customers at the same time they win on the tech savvy younger population.
This research clearly indicates 2 things: 1. Customers are taking advantage of a technological tool to improve their shopping experience (adding value) 2. This is more feasible on the younger population, which is more tech savvy. (trend) 3. The older population (declining) are still going to the brick and mortar stores. (demographic indicator)
Based on this premises, companies should target the younger population by investing in technological platforms that will enable them to market their products via the Internet. In addition, they can also increase product awareness via online advertising and social media. This is a good chance to capitalize on this opportunity.
Today, businesses have to quickly adapt to the changing environment. It is very important that marketing plans account for the dynamic environment and to set the route if they want to remain in business. Failing to change can end up in the company closing its doors for good.
#53 by Pamela Braynen on 9/2/16 - 9:20 PM
#54 by Jennifer Schott on 5/10/17 - 11:52 AM
The convenience of online shopping is changing the way we conduct business. As consumers focus shifts from brick and mortar to e-commerce business have to adapt and provide the consumer with the same options as they would find in stores.
A trend that I see is that brands who are playing the price war online are loosing brand value therefore many of retailers are finding alternative ways by trying to create private label products in order to be competitive on the price point eat.
Millenials have also shifted the way product is bought. Brand loyalty is not something millenials seem to back up and social responsibility also place an important role when making decisions on where to buy and from who.
The retail business needs to adapt to all those new and upcoming customers needs in order to stay in business. You still have your consumers who like to go to a mall and shop and get the product.
If retailers don't adapt to all those changes they won't survive. I dont believe it's just e-commerce it's also a few other changes in the way people shop that have to be adjusted.
#55 by Jessica Socorro on 8/24/17 - 5:42 PM
Traditional retailers are supposed to create and adopt effective strategies which will help them to cope with these threats. For instance, they are expected to automate some of their systems such as service deliveries to ensure that they are fast and convenient to their customers. In doing this, most clients may opt to retain their traditional mode of shopping. Besides, the traditional stores can also extend their services and offer more reliable, timely and cost-effective services than they are currently doing such as offering after sales services something which is not offered through E-commerce though many clients need it. Besides, the traditional retailers can also cut short the shopping journeys for their customers by creating mobile business applications where the business can directly link with their clients. By doing this, they will be able to cater for the welfare of their clients in a more effective way. It is a strategy which will also improve the contact between both parties hence creating an efficient business atmosphere. In general, traditional retailers should study their customers and utilize modern unique strategies and policies which will help them survive in this digital era.
#56 by Narmina on 11/2/17 - 7:35 PM